Week 4: Transnational families and global gifts

Week 4: Transnational families and global gifts

Ryan Schram
ANTH 1002: Anthropology for a better world
ryan.schram@sydney.edu.au
Social Sciences Building 410
August 26, 2025

Main reading: Leinaweaver (2010); Wright (2020)

Song of the day: “Superlovin,” Mark Funk and Danny Cruz. Single. Cruise Music, 2018.

What is your relationship to immigration?

Take out a piece of paper and write your thoughts on this week’s topic: immigration.

• How would you define immigration?
• What is the significance of immigration for the society in which you live?
• What is your personal relationship to immigration?

You can ask the people sitting next to you these questions if you have trouble getting started.

What does immigration look like from a “sending country”?

In an interview, the Fiji Times journalist Felix Chaudhury [FC] asked the acting minister for labor, Filimoni Vosarogo [FV], about the Australia–Fiji guest-worker program known as Pacific Australia Labor Mobility (PALM) scheme:

FC: Another issue that we noted on social media is that Fijian women especially are good at– as maids [FV: Yes.], as housegirls. Will Government– Or, is there any discussion to consider taking housegirls to go there because, you know, we are . good at it, basically. [FV: Yeah.] (Chaudhury interview with Vosarogo 2023, 7:27–7:43)

Vosorogo agreed, saying, “We’re naturals at this sort of thing.” (Chaudhury interview with Vosarogo 2023, 9:21)

• What does migration mean to these two people, and to the government of Fiji?

The right “mentality” for an agricultural laborer is “communal”

In the same interview, Vosorogo said that there was a preference to recruit from rural (iTaukei) Fijian villages for agricultural work in Australia, because it is

a communal type of work, and they would normally also have a communal setting when they relocate overseas. (Kotoisuva 2023)

He also said

[Rural workers] are able to go together as a group, stay together as a group, come back as a group thus improving the image of Fiji as a genuine Vuvale¹ partner. We don’t want to have too many instances of people going overseas and not returning. (Kotoisuva 2023)

What does communal mean for Vosarogo? What does this tell you about his thinking?

What is the right mentality for the Australian employer?

Vosorogo also told an interesting ancedote that I think reveals a lot about how PALM actually works:

There was 11 young men from Rotuma, straight from the island of Rotuma, 11 or twelve, with one of the elders who is second time going across.

But because of his experience. He was there he was doing very well with, ah, he had– he built a good rapport with the employer. The employer specifically wanted people that he– from his own community.

So you got a good thing going now where employers are the ones who are saying “I like this guy.” And so he then tells him, “Look, when you come back, can you recommend that you bring people from your own community?”

As I said, you know, it’s not a discriminatory process. It’s still open to everybody. But identifying people that have the right skill set and also have the character to go, and come back. (5:48–4:48)

• Let’s revisit your answers: What is migration? What happens in Fiji? What happens in Australia?

The encounter between reciprocity and commodification is the major theme in every society’s contemporary history

Reciprocity is part of, and constitutive of, every society. Private property, commodification, and capitalism is part of every society’s contemporary history.

When these two distinct principles interact, many outcomes are possible

• Stripping the obligations from the gift (or imposing a dichotomy of altruism and self-interest on every exchange)
• Segregating reciprocity and commodity consumption in separate spheres
• Subordinating commodity production and exchange to the sphere of reciprocal exchange, causing an efflorescence of systems of reciprocity

and one more

• An informal economy

What is an informal economy?

Throughout the world, there are communities who (1) have little to no means or opportunity to participate in market enterprise, but (2) do not benefit from a fully-developed system of total services in which they can depend on reciprocal ties.

People draw on their reciprocal ties to others to generate capital they can exploit to engage in commodity trade and profit earning, and vice versa.

• Making gin in Frafra “slums” around Accra, Ghana (Hart 1973)
• Selling betel nut around PNG (Sharp 2013, 2016)
• Selling tobacco in Auhelawa

Informal economies: Invisible no more

Informal economies were the buried story of the so-called developing world for most of the 20th century. Now everyone wants to recognize it.

• Nigeria estimates that over half of the nation’s economic activity is informal (Ekugbe 2024). They decided to count it as part of their GDP (Sakr 2025).²

The 21st-century world is an informal economy

The new story is not that the informal economic sector is legitimate and visible. Rather, the world as a whole is getting more informal:

• Global capitalism depends on transnational ties of reciprocity among kin and relatives.
• Wealthy countries are secretly informal. Many people in supposedly developed economies depend on informal economic activity.

Sending money turns your society inside out

In many countries, people are members of households, but households don’t have one location—they span continents.

• In 2023, there were about 15 countries for whom the total value of remittances received was 20% or more of the whole economy.
• In 2018, the total amount of money received from overseas as remittances (personal gifts of money) was more than 25% of all foreign trade in at least 35 countries.
• In at least eight countries, remittances sent from overseas were worth more than all of the country’s exports. The top “export” in these countries is people.
• In India, where the value of international remittances is not a major part of the country’s total economy, people received over US$120 billion last year.
  • This is larger than the value of exports in hundreds of countries, and is larger than the whole economy of at least 100 countries.

Remittances are like an invisible global economy. Even where remittances are not prominent, they are very valuable to many millions of people. They are for many people the main and perhaps only involvment they have in global capitalism. And they are a major part of global capitalism itself.

(For these facts about remittances, see the charts and tables available at the World Bank Open Data web site, especially World Bank 2024b; World Bank 2024a.; see also Ratha et al. 2024)

Come rain or come shine

From 2009 to now, the global economy has been on a rollercoaster ride. But in the background, labor migrants keep sending more and more money home.

Remittances slow a little during global crises, like rapid inflation in 2023, but then rebound. In fact, they have rebounded this year even faster than expected. This chart needs to be updated. The total volume of remittances for 2025 is now projected to be over $900 billion.

Stories of migration

What do remittances mean?

• A world that is getting more and more unequal?
• A new way of doing kinship that extends other practices of care?
• Evidence of how “societies distribute their people” (Siikala 2001)?

People learn to read the presence of immigrants in their society through the lens of narratives of migration

In the film An American Tail (Bluth 1986), a family of mice become new citizens in a “nation of immigrants.” Migration is a symbol, something that stands for something else.

• Moving symbolizes change and liberation of oneself as an individual.
• Migrants cut their ties, uproot themselves, move from an “old country” to a “new frontier” to seek their own fortune, and start a new life.

Despite these powerful migration narratives, there are a lot of other ways to be a migrant

• Migration as circulation, return, and reunion
  • Migration is temporary, and linked to a future transition.
  • Migration uses and maintains links to the home and to one’s existing relatives.
  • Circular migration is government economic policy in Fiji (and many other countries).

In the migration story of reunification, money creates kinship

Sending money home is often not about material or practical concerns. It is not an act of desparation; it’s a specific way of being a global worker, consumer, and citizen.

• A major purpose for remittances sent by Samoans living overseas is faʻalavelave—gifts of money for community projects (Gershon 2012).

• Temporary male migrants from India work to earn money, to buy gold, to give as presents, to support their female kin when they get married. Remittances (of gold) make someone a good brother (Wright 2020).

If you assume that kinship relations are completely different from economic relations, then temporary migration and remittance networks seem strange.

But this is just one example in which the reciprocal ties that define kinship merge with economic activity in a capitalist labor market. Global capitalism is for many a global informal economy and a means to enable the efflorescence of a system of reciprocity at home.

Is the line between home and work the same for everyone?

Take a look at this Mentimeter poll.

Go to https://menti.com. Type in code 5299 0142.

You can also go to this URL: https://www.menti.com/al7yhvs4byjg.

Select as many as apply to the household you grew up in.

Hypothesis: Our class is very diverse and the “male breadwinner” model only applies to some, but not all of us.

“Leveraging teenagers” at Stanford during a pandemic

When Stanford University administrators sent out some advice to their staff about the plans for resumption of on-campus teaching in 2020, they suggested that instructors could consider “leveraging teenagers that might not be engaged” in part-time jobs (Flaherty 2020).

The page has since been deleted from the Stanford University web site but has been archived:

Drell, Persis, and Elizabeth Zacharias. 2020. “Supporting Families during the COVID-19 Pandemic.” Cardinal at Work (Stanford University). July 27, 2020. Accessed Septmeber 7, 2022. http://web.archive.org/web/20201012170506/https://cardinalatwork.stanford.edu/engage/news/supporting-families-during-covid-19-pandemic.

Even before the pandemic, I would argue that the informal economy of care was increasingly necessary to more and more of the middle class in wealthy capitalist societies. It’s not just poor, deprived, or marginalized people who exploit reciprocal ties so they can participate in a capitalist economy.